Monday, August 2, 2010

Departmental inquiry can be quashed if there is inordinate delay: CAT

Departmental inquiry can be quashed if there is inordinate delay: CAT

J. Venkatesan

NEW DELHI: Inordinate and unexplained delay in conducting an enquiry against a delinquent employee after serving the memo for minor charges will vitiate disciplinary proceedings, which can be terminated or quashed without waiting for the enquiry to be completed, the Central Administrative Tribunal has held.

A government employee has some dignity. If one may lose some money, much is not lost, but if he loses his dignity, he may lose everything. Dignity of a government employee, which is the prime concern, cannot be tempered by keeping the enquiry pending for an indefinite period, said Justice V. K. Bali, chairman and L.K. Joshi, vice-chairman of the Principal Bench of the CAT, New Delhi.

The Bench quoting a Supreme Court decision said normally charge sheet or show cause notice should not be quashed by any judicial forum, but there were indeed exceptions to the same and delay in initiating or finalising the departmental proceedings was certainly one such exception.

In the instant case, applicant B.A. Dhayalan, Joint Director, Defence Estates, Central Command, Lucknow, was facing departmental action for minor charges and enquiries started in 1998 and 1999 respectively. Even after the police cleared him in the FIR holding that no case was made out, the proceedings were kept pending and he was denied promotion, while his juniors were promoted . He moved the CAT for quashing the charges.

Allowing the application, the Bench said "there appears to be ring of truth in the contention raised by the applicant that the enquiries are kept pending against him only with a view to stalling his promotion and to see to it that he retires on his present post in humiliation. There cannot be any direct proof of male fides. The facts and circumstances of the case unmistakably at least reveal total callous attitude on the part of the respondents with a pre-determined mind to prolong the enquiries and when it appeared to them that it may not be possible to do so, to inflict punishment upon the applicant. The applicant does not appear to have been met with justice."

The Bench pointed out that enquiry with regard to minor charges had prolonged for over a decade and if the application had not been filed, the respondents would have kept the files of the applicant in their archives.

Respondents

"It is only after the filing of the application that the respondents have woken up from their long slumber and hurriedly tried to finish the matter without following the right procedure with a pre-determined mind to inflict punishment upon the applicant."

The Bench quashed the charge memos and said if the applicant was found fit for promotion as per the recommendations of the Departmental Promotion Committee, he should be immediately promoted with all consequential benefits.

© Copyright 2000 - 2009 The Hindu

Courtesy_

No comments:

Post a Comment

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Search our Blog here

Google
 

Compiled by

முதன்மை நாட்கள்

Disclaimer


This Blog Spot is meant for publishing landmark judgments pronounced by the Court of law as we collected from the renowned Dailies, Magazines, etc., so as to create an awareness to the general public and also to keep it as a ready reckoner by them. As such the readers may extend their gratitude towards the Original Author as we quoted at the bottom of each Post under the title "Courtesy". Furthermore, the Blog Authors are no way responsible for the correctness of the materials published herein and the readers may verify the concerned valuable sources.



Followers

Dinamalar | Court News Feed

Dinakaran | Crime News Feed

Labels

Madras High Court (192) Supreme Court (142) Madurai Bench (52) High Court (44) tamil nadu (42) Advocate (38) Delhi High Court (36) Education (30) Indian Kanoon (30) Divorce (28) Pondicherry (27) Husband (26) Wife (26) consumer forum (23) Lawyers (21) police (20) Cr.P.C. (19) Consumer (18) 2013 (16) Judges (15) Matrimonial case (15) Cruelty (13) Maintenance (13) AIADMK (12) Bank (12) IPC (12) dmk (12) Criminal cases (11) Hindu Marriage Act (11) Jayalalithaa (11) School (11) Woman (11) article (11) election (11) karnataka high court (11) the hindu (11) Bar Council of India (10) Child (10) Compensation (10) Kerala High Court (10) election commission (10) medical (10) Labour cases (9) Madurai (9) Marriage (9) Mobile Phone (9) dinamani (9) evidence (9) pil (9) tamil nadu bar council (9) tax (9) CJI (8) Cell Phone (8) Loans (8) MV ACT CASES (8) Magistrate (8) Rent Control Act (8) State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (8) doctors (8) insurance (8) taxation (8) Accident cases (7) Bar Council (7) Constitution (7) Examination (7) Frontline (7) Gujarat High Court (7) Negligence (7) Tenant Landlord (7) court (7) 2012 (6) Allahabad high court (6) Andhra Pradesh High Court (6) Civil Judge (6) Complaint (6) Consumer National Commission (6) Domestic Violence Act (6) Dowry (6) Employee (6) Justice G. Rajasuria (6) Muslims (6) Notification (6) Railway (6) Reservation Quota (6) USA (6) arbitration (6) madras (6) rape (6) rulings (6) sex (6) Airlines (5) College (5) Employer (5) FIR (5) Labour Court (5) Mumbai High Court (5) President (5) Rajiv Gandhi (5) Recruitment (5) Sethusamudram ship canal (5) Student (5) TRAI (5) advertisement (5) appointment (5) bombay high court (5) compassionate (5) deficiency of service (5) fined (5) new delhi (5) Andhra Pradesh (4) BSNL (4) Commissioner of Police (4) Corruption (4) Daughter (4) Death penalty (4) Delay (4) Father (4) Fees (4) Foreigners Act (4) Hindu (4) Hospitals (4) Judgment (4) Judiciary (4) Justice G.Rajasuria (4) Karunanidhi (4) Life Imprisonment (4) Matrimonial House (4) Ministry of Law (4) Private Schools (4) Ram Sethu project (4) Sexual exploitation (4) Suspension (4) Tenant (4) Transfer (4) contempt (4) delhi (4) editorial (4) hindustan times (4) karnataka (4) times of india (4) us (4) Adoption (3) Aircraft (3) Assassination (3) Ban (3) Bank Cases (3) Bigamy (3) Calcutta High Court (3) Cheque (3) Chief Minister of Pondicherry (3) Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu (3) Civil Matters (3) Computer (3) Dinakaran (3) Electricity (3) Encroachers (3) Eviction (3) Gazette (3) Hindu Adoption and Maintenance Act (3) Human Rights (3) Human Rights Commission (3) Income Tax (3) Justice Ashok Kumar (3) Landlord (3) Law Firms (3) Limitation Act (3) Medicos (3) Murder case (3) Muslim (3) NDNC (3) Negotiable Instruments Act (3) Panchayats Act (3) Parents (3) Patent (3) Prisoner (3) Proterty Act (3) Punishment (3) RTE Act (3) Ragging (3) Salaries (3) Selection (3) Smoking (3) Strikes (3) Subramanian Swamy (3) Teachers (3) Telephone (3) Theft (3) Villupuram (3) Witness (3) Woman Lawyers (3) Workman (3) Youtube (3) parliament (3) pmk (3) registration department (3) software (3) stamp act (3) 2007 (2) Aadhaar Card (2) Abortion (2) Absence (2) Acquittal (2) Actor (2) Airport (2) Airtel (2) Amendments (2) Apple (2) Arrest (2) Assault (2) BCCI (2) BCI (2) Britain (2) CBI (2) CBSE (2) CJ (2) CNN IBN (2) Chenai Corporation (2) Child Witness (2) Cigarette (2) Citizenship (2) Coimbatore (2) Collector (2) Companies Act (2) Complainant (2) Congress (2) Copyright (2) Court Fees (2) Date of Birth (2) Dayanidhi Maran (2) Disqualification (2) Driving Licence (2) Drugs (2) EVMs (2) Enrolment (2) Evening Court (2) Eye-witness (2) Family (2) Family Court (2) Foreign Law Firms (2) Freedom Fighters (2) Fundamental Rights (2) Google (2) Grave crimes (2) Habeas Corpus (2) Haldiram (2) Health Ministry (2) Himachal Pradesh High Court (2) ID Act (2) IT Act (2) Impeachment (2) Inter-caste (2) Interest (2) Interim Injunction (2) International Arbitration (2) International Court of Justice (2) Internet (2) Job (2) Justice (2) Justice A.K.Ganguly (2) Justice Dinakaran (2) LPG (2) LTTE (2) Law Commission (2) Law Department (2) Lok Adalat (2) MPs (2) Madhya Pradesh High Court (2) Maharashtra (2) Mark Sheets (2) Medi-claim (2) Men (2) Microsoft (2) Minor Child (2) Municipal Post (2) Municipal Waste (2) Nagapattinam (2) Nalini (2) Nuke Deal (2) PTI (2) Patient (2) Penalty (2) Pension (2) Police Reforms Committee (2) Poll freebies (2) Pregnant (2) Prevention of Corruption Act (2) Prime Minister (2) Property (2) Public Meetings (2) Public Property (2) Punjab High Court (2) RBI (2) RTI Act (2) Registrar (2) Release (2) Reserve Bank of India (2) Retired benefits (2) Review (2) Road (2) SBI (2) SHRC (2) Samacheer Kalvi (2) Sanjay Dutt (2) Self-defence (2) Sikkim (2) Sonia Gandhi (2) State Bar Concil (2) TADA (2) TNEB (2) Tamil New Year Act (2) Tobacco firms (2) Trafficking (2) University (2) Video (2) Vigilance (2) Vodafone (2) Wages (2) Water (2) Websites (2) West Bengal (2) Wikipedia (2) Woman Judges (2) backlog of cases (2) bail (2) customs duty (2) girl (2) laptops (2) legislature (2) service (2) service tax (2) sessions judge (2) tiruchi (2) 100 RUPEE (1) 2001 (1) 2006 (1) 2009 (1) 2014 (1) 6th Pay Scale (1) AIIMS (1) Aadal Paadal (1) Aadhar Card (1) Abuse (1) Accountable (1) Act (1) Adjournments (1) Adverse possession (1) Advocate Cyril Mathias Vincent (1) Advocate M.Kumaran (1) Advocate M.S.Maruthupandiyan (1) Agitating (1) Agreement (1) Agriculture (1) Air India (1) Alien Species (1) Allahabad (1) Allergy (1) Allopathy (1) Amusement parks (1) Answer Sheets (1) Apartments (1) Appearance (1) Arguments (1) Arrears (1) Arunachal Pradesh (1) Ashok Kumar (1) Assembly Speaker (1) Assets case (1) Association (1) Attendance (1) Attention Please (1) Auditors (1) Australia (1) Autopsy (1) Ayodhya (1) BJP (1) Babri Masjid (1) Baby (1) Baggage missing (1) Bank Account (1) Bar Association (1) Batco Roadways' case (1) Bhavani Singh (1) Bhopal gas tragedy (1) Bhullar's mercy plea (1) Big TV (1) Bihar (1) Bill (1) Biscuits (1) Black Sea (1) Bofors case (1) Bonus (1) Boycott (1) Brain-mapping (1) Brothers (1) Burqa (1) Buses (1) Business Line (1) Bye-laws (1) CAT (1) CEC (1) CIC (1) CITY CIVIL COURT (1) CPC (1) CTC (1) CTV (1) Calcutta (1) Cambodian (1) Camera (1) Canada (1) Cargo Ship (1) Caste (1) Cauvery (1) Cauvery Tribunal Award (1) Central Crime Branch (1) Certificates (1) Chennai (South) Forum (1) Chhattisgarh State Bar Council (1) Chief Judicial Magistrate (1) Child Marriage Act (1) Christian (1) Civic Election (1) Code of Civil procedure (1) Commonwealth Games Panel (1) Communal harmony (1) Compounding Offences (1) Condoms (1) Constitution Bench (1) Contract labour (1) Conversion Formula (1) Cooperative Societies (1) Copying (1) Corporation (1) Cosmetic (1) Costumes (1) Court Buildings (1) Creche (1) Credit Card (1) Cricket (1) Culcutta High Court (1) Current Tamil Nadu Cases (1) Custodial death (1) DGP (1) DK (1) DMDK (1) DNA Test (1) DRT (1) Dalits (1) Damages (1) Dasavatharam (1) Daughter-in-law (1) Death (1) Debarring (1) Deccan (1) Defaulters (1) Degree (1) Departmental Enquiry (1) Derogatory remarks (1) Desertion (1) Designation (1) Destruction (1) Detergent Soap (1) Dharmapuri (1) Directory (1) Disconnection (1) District Judges (1) Don Bosco Matriculation School (1) Don Bosco School (1) Download Links (1) Dozing (1) Dr.Ramadoss (1) Dress Code (1) Driver (1) Drunk driving (1) Dying Declaration (1) EPIC (1) ESI Act (1) EU (1) Education Department (1) Education Loan (1) Elevation (1) Emergency (1) Engineering College (1) Enquiry (1) Entertainment tax (1) Environment (1) European Court (1) Exam Cheaters (1) Exam Marks (1) Exit Polls (1) Experts Committee (1) Expulsion (1) Facebook (1) Fair Criticism (1) False (1) Father-in-law (1) Film (1) Fire (1) Flats (1) Food (1) France (1) French Civil Code (1) French Regime (1) Fringe Benefit Tax (1) Frivolous Petition (1) Garments (1) Gauhati HC (1) Gender Bias (1) Girlfriend (1) Goa (1) Gondas (1) Goods (1) Goons (1) Government Offices (1) Government Officials (1) Governors (1) Govt. sites (1) Grandchildren (1) Gratuity (1) Green Card (1) Gubernatorial (1) Gudalur Janmam Estates (1) Guidelines (1) Guilty (1) HIV Patient (1) HRCE Act (1) Hamam Soap (1) Handcuff (1) Haryana (1) Hawkers (1) Heroin (1) Hewlett Packard (1) Highways (1) Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowment (1) Hindus (1) Hindustan Lever Limited (1) Hindustan Unilever Limited (1) Hoardings (1) Holiday Court (1) Holidays (1) Hostel (1) Hutchison Essar (1) Hyderabad (1) ICICI (1) ICJ (1) ICSE (1) IMDT Act (1) IPL (1) IT Tax Tribunal (1) Identity Cards (1) Illegitimate (1) Images (1) Immoral (1) Impotent (1) Imprisonment (1) Incest (1) Infiltrators (1) Interest rates (1) Interim Orders (1) Interview (1) Invalid (1) Investigation (1) Jammu and Kashmir (1) Jharkhand (1) Journal Section (1) Judicial Officers (1) Judicial Staffs (1) Junction (1) Justice A.P.Shah (1) Justice G Rajasuriya (1) Justice Rajasuriya (1) Juvenile Justice Board (1) K.R.Narayanan (1) K.Veeramani (1) KFC (1) Kabil Sibal (1) Kachatheevu (1) Karaikal (1) Kerla (1) Khushboo (1) Kidney (1) Kingfisher (1) Kodak (1) Lakes (1) Land Owners (1) Larger Bench (1) Laundry (1) Law College (1) Lawyer Notice (1) Legal Practitioners Act 2010 (1) Leprosy Patient (1) License Fees (1) Lift (1) Links (1) Local Bodies (1) Lok Sabha (1) MCOCA (1) MLAs (1) MNC (1) Malaria (1) Malaysian Airlines (1) Malpractice (1) Mangalore Express (1) Married (1) Mediation (1) Meghalaya (1) Mercy Petition (1) Mizoram (1) Mobile Court (1) Mosquito Bite (1) Mother (1) Motor Vehicle (1) Municipality (1) Mutual Consent (1) NDPS Act (1) NDTV (1) NH 31A (1) NOTA (1) NPT (1) NRI (1) NSA Act (1) Nagaland (1) Nallathambi (1) Narco Analysis (1) National Highways (1) Natural Justice (1) Navarasu murder case (1) Negative Voting (1) Nepal (1) No-confidence motion (1) Non-signatory (1) None of the Above (1) Norms (1) North Carolina (1) Notary Public (1) Notifications (1) Nursing College (1) Obscenity (1) Office Bearers (1) Official Language (1) Oil Companies (1) Online (1) Oral (1) Ordinance (1) Orissa High Court (1) PBA (1) PF (1) PHCs (1) PIB (1) PNDT Act (1) Panorama view (1) Parle Marie (1) Partnership (1) Paternity (1) Patna High Court (1) Patta (1) Pending case (1) Pondicherry Code (1) Pondicherry University (1) Port (1) Possession (1) Postmortem (1) Power (1) Prabha Sridevan (1) Preamble (1) Premarital sex (1) Press Trust of India (1) Prestige (1) Private (1) Private Defence (1) Prize Draw Contest (1) Profession (1) Promotion (1) Prosecution (1) Protest (1) Provident Fund (1) Public Prosecutor (1) Puducherry Code (1) Punjab and Haryana High Court (1) Quash (1) Quattrocchi (1) Quick Links (1) RCOP (1) RDBFI Act (1) RIM (1) RPF (1) Railway Budget (1) Rajasthan High Court (1) Rajasuria (1) Rajya Sabha (1) Re-name (1) Recovery (1) Refund (1) Regional SC Bench (1) Regulations (1) Reinstatement (1) Relatives (1) Reliance (1) Religion (1) Religious Functions (1) Remanding (1) Removal (1) Repeal of Local Laws (1) Respondent (1) Revaluation (1) Rexona Soap (1) Right to Information Act (1) Right to Sleep (1) Rigorous imprisonment (1) Rin (1) Romania (1) Rural (1) SC/ST (1) SMS (1) SPP (1) Sachar Commission (1) Sale (1) Sanction (1) Saree (1) Scam (1) Secretary (1) Security (1) Senior Advocate (1) Serials (1) Service matters (1) Settlement (1) Shankaracharya case (1) Sheristadar (1) Ship (1) Sivaji Ganesan Statue (1) Sleeping (1) Soap (1) Son (1) Special Marriages Act (1) Sri Lanka (1) Sri Meenakshi Sundareswarar Temple (1) State Govts. (1) Suicide (1) Sukanya (1) Surgery (1) TNPSC (1) TV (1) Tamil Links (1) Telecom (1) Telegraph Act (1) Temples (1) Thanthai Periyar (1) Third Party (1) Thirunelveli (1) Ticket Bookings (1) Ticket less Journey (1) Tide (1) Time-barred matters (1) Title suit (1) Toronto (1) Trademarks (1) Traffic (1) Transfer Certificate (1) Transport Authority (1) Travels Agent (1) Trees (1) Tripurar (1) Turban law (1) USE Act (1) Ukraine (1) Union Carbide Corporation (1) Union Minister (1) Universities (1) Uttarakhand (1) Uttaranchal (1) VAO (1) VRS (1) Vacuum Cleaner (1) Vakalat (1) Vaseline (1) Verbal (1) Video Poker (1) Video-conferencing (1) Vijayakant (1) Visa (1) Voters (1) Voting (1) Wakf (1) Watchman (1) Who's Who (1) Word (1) Workmen Compensation Act (1) Wrong Provision (1) Yahoo (1) architects (1) azhagiri (1) british airways (1) churidar (1) deccan herald (1) delh (1) double taxation (1) e-Library (1) eBay (1) eCourt (1) ebc (1) farmers loan waiver (1) germany citizen (1) guideline value (1) guruvayur devaswom (1) hMatrimonial case (1) helmet (1) india (1) law and order (1) nawaz sharif (1) pakistan (1) pakistan supreme court (1) practical lawyer (1) practitioners (1) pratiba (1) promise (1) rules (1) sand mining (1) southern districts (1) uk (1) warrants for cash scam (1) தூக்கம் (1)